Mike Mullaney All articles
Client Delivery

Three Boxes, One Honest Conversation: Quoting So Clients Choose the Right Problem

Mike Mullaney
Three Boxes, One Honest Conversation: Quoting So Clients Choose the Right Problem

Photo: UK business consultant and client reviewing three proposal options at a meeting table, via upload.wikimedia.org

The problem with a single number

A single-price proposal looks decisive. It is not. It is a starting gun for a different conversation: can you do it cheaper, can you take out the training, can we phase the bit you clearly think is optional. By the time the client has finished trimming, you are delivering a thinner version of the thing you originally believed in, and nobody is quite sure who agreed to what.

I started quoting in threes because I got tired of watching good projects get nibbled into mediocre ones. Not because I enjoy building spreadsheets with more tabs than a wedding seating plan. Three tiers do something a single price cannot: they force the client to choose a version of the future rather than negotiate down a version of the past.

What each box actually says

The lean option is real. That matters. A fake cheap tier is the fastest way to lose trust. My lean box is the smallest sensible piece of work that addresses the presenting problem: configure what exists, fix the obvious breakage, train one person, leave a note. It is not a punishment. It is what you buy when cash is tight and the problem can wait a quarter.

The standard option is usually the one that covers the actual brief with proper discovery, sensible data work, a bit of change management and enough documentation that the client is not ringing me at Christmas. It is the option most clients choose, which is the uncomfortable lesson I will come to.

The third box is the one that solves the awkward problem properly. Not the fantasy scope. The awkward problem: the data is filthy, the process has three owners, the integration nobody mentioned, the team that will quietly refuse to use it. This tier is not there to make the middle look reasonable. It is there to tell the truth about what proper looks like.

A worked example: the CRM that was not the problem

A 40-person specialist distributor in the Midlands asked for a new CRM. The sales director wanted better pipeline visibility. The operations manager wanted fewer duplicate records. The managing director wanted fewer arguments in the Monday meeting. Three different problems wearing the same software-shaped coat.

My lean quote was £5,700 ex VAT: six days at £650 to configure the existing system, clean the obvious duplicates and run a short training session. It would have made the screens nicer and solved roughly none of the underlying issue, which was that two teams were using different definitions of a customer.

The standard quote was £12,800 ex VAT: discovery, a proper data clean, a single customer definition, two training sessions and four weeks of hand-holding. That is the box I expected them to pick, and they did.

The proper-fix quote was £23,000 ex VAT: the standard work plus migration from the old quoting spreadsheet, an integration with accounts, and a change process for the two teams who were going to resist. Expensive, unglamorous, and the only one that dealt with the real awkwardness.

All prices were ex VAT. UK clients need that stated plainly, not buried under a table. VAT at 20% changes the cash conversation, especially for smaller firms, and pretending otherwise makes you look like you are hiding something.

The conversation the tiers force

When you put three boxes on the table, the client stops asking whether the price is fair and starts asking what they actually value. That is a better question. Do they want the pain to go away, or do they want the invoice to be smaller? Both are legitimate. Only one of them is a project.

It also exposes scope erosion early. If the client says they want the lean option but also want the integration, the data migration and the training, you can point at the page. That is not you being difficult. That is the quote doing its job.

I use day rates openly in these conversations. Mine is £650 for consultancy work, and I show the days. If the client wants to remove days, we can talk about what comes out. What we do not do is pretend that the same outcome costs less because the meeting ran long.

The uncomfortable bit

Most clients pick the middle. I have stopped being surprised by that. The middle feels responsible. It is not the cheapest and it is not the frightening one. It is the option that says: I am taking this seriously, but I am not buying a new boiler as well.

The top tier rarely gets picked on the first pass. That used to annoy me. Now I see it as the point. The top tier changes the conversation even when it is not chosen, because it names the awkward problem out loud. Six months later, when the awkward problem reappears, nobody can say it was never mentioned.

The lean tier is the one I hope they do not pick. Not because I do not want the work, but because I have watched too many lean projects turn into a slow, polite argument about why the software did not fix the process. If the client genuinely cannot afford the proper fix, I would rather say so and schedule the work for when they can than sell them the cheap version and pretend it is the same thing.

Three boxes do not guarantee a perfect project. They do guarantee an honest starting point. In my experience, that is worth more than a single number that looks tidy.

All Articles

Related Articles

A Brief You Can Read Standing Up: How One Page Beats a Twenty-Page SOW

A Brief You Can Read Standing Up: How One Page Beats a Twenty-Page SOW

Closing Time: The Twelve-Point Handover Check I Run Before Any Project Ends

Closing Time: The Twelve-Point Handover Check I Run Before Any Project Ends

Reply Tomorrow: The Client Boundary That Makes You Easier to Trust

Reply Tomorrow: The Client Boundary That Makes You Easier to Trust